Choosing colors for a photo pattern

A photo has thousands of colors. Your project will have a handful. Which ones you keep, and how different they are from each other, decides whether people recognise the picture.

How many colors?

Fewer than you think. Every color is another bobbin to manage, more color changes, more ends to weave in, and more yarn to buy in whole skeins. A rough guide:

The chart size matters as much as the color count. Small charts can't show subtle shading, because there are not enough stitches for a gradient to form. If a picture looks muddy, try fewer colors before you try more.

Contrast matters more than hue

From a few steps away, the eye reads light and dark first and color second. Two yarns that look very different on the shelf, say a medium red and a medium green, can be almost the same lightness, and the edge between them disappears in the finished piece.

Check value with a grey photo

Take a photo of your chosen skeins side by side and turn it black and white on your phone. If two of them look the same grey, the picture will lose detail wherever they meet. Swap one for a lighter or darker shade. Do the same with the chart on screen: if the subject doesn't stand out in grey, it won't stand out in yarn.

Keep a clear background

The background is usually the biggest color in the chart. A background that is clearly lighter or darker than the subject makes everything else easier. Busy photo backgrounds are best replaced with one plain color: paint or fill over them in the editor, or merge the background colors into one.

Watch out for the middle tones

Automatic color reduction tends to spend colors on tiny differences in mid-tones, like two nearly identical beiges in a cat's fur. Merging those into one frees up a color for something that matters, like the eyes.

Matching to real yarn

Choosing colors from a yarn line you can actually buy saves a second round of guessing at the shop. LoopChart can match the palette to the shades of popular yarn brands, such as Red Heart Super Saver, Stylecraft Special DK or Paintbox Simply DK, and others. Screens show color differently, so treat on-screen yarn colors as approximations and check against real skeins or a shade card when you can, especially for skin tones and greys.

Pick one yarn line for the whole project if possible. Different brands of the same weight can still differ in thickness, which shows up as uneven stitches.

Cleaning up confetti stitches

Photos produce single, isolated stitches of a color in the middle of another color, often called confetti. On screen they look like texture. In yarn each one means joining a color, working one stitch, and cutting or carrying it again, plus two more ends to weave in. They also rarely improve the picture.

Here is a small patch before and after cleaning. C is a third color that only appears as single stitches:

Before: four single C stitches scattered through the chart.
123456
5AAACAA
4ABBBAA
3CBBBBA
2ABBCBA
1AABBAC
After: each stray stitch takes the color of its neighbours.
123456
5AAAAAA
4ABBBAA
3ABBBBA
2ABBBBA
1AABBAA

Four fewer color changes and eight fewer ends, and the shape is cleaner. In LoopChart the clean up stray stitches button does this across the whole chart in one go: it replaces single stitches that don't match any of their neighbours. It is undoable, so you can compare before and after.

When to keep a lone stitch

Some single stitches are the picture: the highlight in an eye, the dot of an i, a nose. After cleaning, look over the chart and paint those back by hand with the eyedropper and paint tools.

A quick routine

  1. Crop the photo tightly around the subject.
  2. Start with the automatic palette, then lower the color count until the picture just starts to lose something, and go back one.
  3. Merge near-duplicate colors and make the background a single color.
  4. Clean up stray stitches, then restore the few that matter.
  5. Check the chart in grey for contrast.
  6. Look at the yarn estimate per color: a color used for only a few dozen stitches might be one you can drop, or one you can buy as a mini skein.

For the technique-specific side, see the C2C graph generator, tapestry crochet charts and photo to knitting chart guides.

Questions people ask

How many colors should a photo blanket have?

Four to six suits most pets, cartoons and simple photos. Portraits may need seven to ten on a large chart. On small charts, more colors usually add noise rather than detail.

What are confetti stitches?

Single stitches of one color surrounded by other colors. They come from photo noise, add a color change and two ends each, and rarely help the picture. LoopChart's clean-up button removes them in one step.

Are the yarn brand colors exact?

No. They are on-screen approximations of the real shades. Screens vary, so compare with real skeins or a shade card before buying a lot of yarn.

How can I tell if my colors have enough contrast?

Turn a photo of the skeins, or the chart, black and white. Colors that turn into the same grey will blur together in the finished piece.